View all the state titles and state final appearances made by the Cardinal McCarrick Eagles. Since 1919, McCarrick has six state final appearances, but never won a state title in boys basketball. After appearing in six state finals since 1948, the Eagles last appeared in a state final in 2011. Cardinal McCarrick, which was previously named St. Mary’s of South Amboy closed in 2015.
Cardinal McCarrick Eagles (0-6)–State Finals Appearances
| Year | Classification | Opponent | Result |
| 1948 | Non-Public B | Holy Family (Union City) | Won |
| 1951 | Non-Public B | St. Mary’s (Elizabeth) | Won |
| 1980 | Non-Public B | St. Anthony’s | Lost |
| 2003 | Non-Public B | St. Patrick’s | Lost |
| 2005 | Non-Public B | St. Patrick’s | Lost |
| 2011 | Non-Public B | St. Anthony’s | Lost |