View all the sectional titles won by the Carteret Ramblers. Since 1919, Carteret has won 11 sectional championships. Winning all eleven sectional titles since 1930, the Ramblers last won a sectional final in 2000. Carteret last appeared in a sectional final in 2018.
Carteret Ramblers–Sectional Titles
| Year | Classification | Section |
| 1930 | Group III | Central |
| 1932 | Group III | Central |
| 1934 | Group II | Central |
| 1945 | Group II | Central |
| 1950 | Group II | Central |
| 1953 | Group II | Central |
| 1954 | Group III | Central |
| 1957 | Group II | Central |
| 1960 | Group II | Central |
| 1988 | Group II | Central |
| 2000 | Group II | Central |