| Player Name | Points Scored | Year Graduated |
| Tyje’ Kelton | 1,942 | 2020 |
| Drew Johnson | 1,480 | 2021 |
| David Johnson | 1,350 | 2015 |
| Tim Connery | 1,271 | 1987 |
| Ted Shattle | 1,222 | 1992 |
| Andrew Butula | 1,220 | 1960 |
| Tom Nagel | 1,144 | 1977 |
| Dylan Hoski | 1,128 | 2013 |
Dunellen’s 1,000 Point Scorers