| Player Name | Points Scored | Year Graduated |
| Artie Flaherty | 2,052 | 1985 |
| Larry Spigner | 1,712 | 1989 |
| DeJuan Miller | 1,390 | 2008 |
| Dominic Schiappa | 1,372 | 2022 |
| Cameron Hayes-Durina | 1,143 | 2026 |
| Rich Toth | 1,120 | 1971 |
| Joe Wert | 1,102 | 1984 |
| Brad Sellers | 1,061 | 1976 |
| Artie Flaherty Jr. | 1,052 | 2015 |
| Mike Crusco | 1,048 | 2011 |
| Chris Carr | 1,046 | 2003 |