View all the state titles and state final appearances made by the New Brunswick Zebras. Since 1919, New Brunswick has made eight state final appearances, and has won four state crowns in boys basketball. After appearing in eight state finals over a span of 57 years, the Zebras have not appeared in a state final since 1984.
New Brunswick Zebras–State Titles
| Year | Classification |
| 1930 | Group IV |
| 1938 | Group IV |
| 1944 | Group IV |
| 1984 | Group I |
New Brunswick Zebras (4-4)–State Finals Appearances
| Year | Classification | Opponent | Result |
| 1928 | Group IV | Trenton | Lost |
| 1930 | Group IV | Union Hill | Won |
| 1935 | Group IV | Trenton | Lost |
| 1938 | Group IV | Memorial (West New York) | Won |
| 1944 | Group IV | Camden | Won |
| 1955 | Group IV | Union Hill | Lost |
| 1983 | Group I | Abraham Clark (Roselle) | Lost |
| 1984 | Group I | Mahwah | Won |