| Player Name | Points Scored | Year Graduated |
| Tim Klag* | 1,570 | 1989 |
| Tyler Drews | 1,468 | 2014 |
| Sultan Aminu | 1,225 | 2013 |
| Connor Romano | 1,004 | 2016 |
| Julius Belton | 1,001 | 2019 |
| Dan Singleton | 973 | 1995 |
*–Played at Cedar Ridge High School (closed in June, 1994).
Old Bridge’s 1,000 Point Scorers