View all the sectional titles won by the Piscataway Chiefs. Since 1919, Piscataway has won four sectional championships. Winning all four sectional finals since 1963, the Chiefs last won a sectional final in 2008. Piscataway won back to back sectional crowns in 1994 and 1995.
Piscataway Chiefs–Sectional Titles
| Year | Classification | Section |
| 1963 | Group II | Central |
| 1994 | Group IV | Central |
| 1995 | Group IV | Central |
| 2008 | Group IV | North Section 2 |