| Player Name | Points Scored | Year Graduated |
| Ed Behnen | 1,993 | 2000 |
| Brian Seres | 1,632 | 2007 |
| Curt Wood | 1,630 | 1968 |
| Pete Smith | 1,576 | 1984 |
| Gary Kuhn | 1,543 | 1991 |
| Kyle Gasiewski | 1,382 | 2019 |
| Frank Kuziemski | 1,323 | 1979 |
| Steve Herdman | 1,229 | 2014 |
| Nick Shaw | 1,214 | 2003 |
| Gary Lange | 1,167 | 1972 |
| Joe Charmello | 1,143 | 2010 |
| Joe Bartlinski | 1,135 | 2006 |
| Bill Clayton | 1,118 | 1967 |
| Gavin Pelkey | 1,062 | 2024 |
| Bob Clayton | 1,011 | 1978 |
| Joe Fruncillo | 1,003 | 2014 |