| Player Name | Points Scored | Year Graduated |
| Jake Dadika | 1,693 | 2014 |
| Charlie Eibeler | 1,633 | 1995 |
| Geno Zimmerlink | 1,302 | 1981 |
| Matt Vento | 1,293 | 2019 |
| Dave Curry | 1,211 | 2003 |
| Eric Dadika | 1,191 | 2016 |
| Marlon Hart | 1,182 | 2016 |
| Cody Pace | 1,155 | 2010 |
| Kiye Walker | 1,140 | 2024 |
| Jean Georges | 1,133 | 2003 |
| Daniel Yarus | 1,101 | 2024 |
| Anthony Pratola | 1,093 | 1993 |
| Tommy Soulias | 1,043 | 2012 |
| Jason Konek | 1,013 | 1991 |
| Ross Gerhart | 1,013 | 2009 |