View all the state titles and state final appearances made by the St. Peter’s Cardinals. Since 1919, St. Peter’s made 13 state final appearances, and has won three state crowns in boys basketball. After appearing in the 1995 state championship, the Cardinals did not play in another state final before closing in 2007.
St. Peter’s Cardinals–State Titles
| Year | Classification |
| 1936 | Non-Public A |
| 1939 | Non-Public A |
| 1968 | Non-Public B |
St. Peter’s Cardinals (3-10)–State Finals Appearances
| Year | Classification | Opponent | Result |
| 1935 | Non-Public A | St. Mary’s-Rutherford | Lost |
| 1936 | Non-Public A | Good Counsel (Newark) | Won |
| 1939 | Non-Public A | Immaculate Conception (Montclair) | Won |
| 1943 | Non-Public A | St. Mary’s-Elizabeth | Lost |
| 1954 | Non-Public A | St. Peter’s-Jersey City | Lost |
| 1956 | Non-Public A | St. Peter’s-Jersey City | Lost |
| 1967 | Non-Public B | St. Mary’s-Jersey City | Lost |
| 1968 | Non-Public B | St. Mary’s-Elizabeth | Won |
| 1983 | Non-Public B | St. Anthony’s | Lost |
| 1984 | Non-Public B | St. Anthony’s | Lost |
| 1985 | Non-Public B | St. Anthony’s | Lost |
| 1990 | Non-Public B | St. Anthony’s | Lost |
| 1995 | Non-Public B | St. Anthony’s | Lost |