| Player Name | School | Points Scored | Year Graduated |
| John Somogyi | St. Peter’s | 3,310 | 1968 |
| Blake Taylor | Perth Amboy | 2,541 | 1975 |
| Brian Taylor | Perth Amboy | 2,495 | 1969 |
| Deon Jackson | South River | 2,307 | 1991 |
| Alex Grospe | South River | 2,173 | 2025 |
| Jalen Fleming | Timothy Christian | 2,152 | 2025 |
| Derrick Whitaker | South River | 2,105 | 2019 |
| Artie Flaherty | Metuchen | 2,052 | 1985 |
| Gary Brokaw | New Brunswick | 2,028 | 1971 |
| Jerry Paluch | St. Mary’s – Perth Amboy | 2,023 | 1966 |